When we read the full range of counsel that Ellen White has on a topic, the
picture is often quite different than when we are dealing with only a part of
her material or with isolated quotations. Many times in her long ministry Ellen
White had to deal with those who took only part of her counsel. "When it
suits your purpose," she told the delegates of the 1891 General Conference
session, "you treat the Testimonies as if you believed them, quoting from
them to strengthen any statement you wish to have prevail. But how is it when
light is given to correct your errors? Do you then accept the light? When the
Testimonies speak contrary to your ideas, you treat them very lightly"
(ibid., p. 43). It is important to listen to all the counsel.
Along this line we find two approaches to the Ellen G. White writings. One
assembles all her pertinent material on the subject. The other selects from Mrs.
White only those sentences, paragraphs, or more extensive materials that can be
employed to support a particular emphasis. The only faithful approach is the
first. One important step in being true to Ellen White's intent is to read
widely in the available counsel on a topic.
But not only must we base our conclusion on the entire spectrum of her
thought on a topic; our conclusion must harmonize with the overall tenor of the
body of her writings. Not only bias, but also unsound premises, faulty
reasoning, or other misuses of her material, can lead to false conclusions.